What's a great book that was poorly executed in a movie?

8

8 Answers

Levi F. Profile
Levi F. answered

Ender's Game

Excellent book--movie was mediocre at best.

Didge Doo Profile
Didge Doo answered

The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo et al. They tried to pack too much into three ordinary-length movies. It didn't work.

8 People thanked the writer.
HappyTo BeHereTo
HappyTo BeHereTo commented
I thought that movie "stank." Some liked it, but I was frustrated. Besides your excellent point, they mumbled.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
The books were great. I don't know how they stuffed the movies so badly.
Virginia Lou Profile
Virginia Lou answered

Dear HappyTwo,

I also used this as a GOOD example of a book that was rendered well in the movie version...

But I was entranced by LILITH, starring Warren Beatty, Jean Seberg, and Peter Fonda, based on the book by J.R. Salamanca. The acting was exquisite, but the book was so fine and subtle that I could not really appreciate the movie until reading the book.

No fault of Director Robert Rossen, just no way the story could have been rendered any better I believe; an amazing and sympathetic study of madness.


Rooster Cogburn Profile
Rooster Cogburn , Rooster Cogburn, answered

The Hunt for Red October ! Movie was OK but not any where near as good as the book.


Jaimie  JT Profile
Jaimie JT answered

I loved the book Flowers in the Attic when I was a kid ... The movie was shizit. That was a hundred years ago though so I'm over it.

6 People thanked the writer.
HappyTo BeHereTo
HappyTo BeHereTo commented
BAM!!! The self improvement seminar paid off!!! You can get over "it"="shizit".
...
I'm so darn proud of you.
Jaimie  JT
Jaimie JT commented
BAM !!! I'm so over the shizit :p ummmmm was I in a self improvement seminar ???
Janis Haskell Profile
Janis Haskell answered


Answer Question

Anonymous